(07) 4944 2000
Local people. Local expertise. Industry leaders
Facebook
LinkedIn
MacAmiet Logo White
  • Home
  • About
    • Profile
    • Privacy and Credit Reporting Policy
    • History
    • Career Opportunities
    • Offers
  • People
    • Directors
      • Gene Paterson
      • Pat Carroll
      • John Formosa
      • Darren Sekac
      • Stuart Naylor
      • Andrew Telford
      • Samantha Sticklan
      • Paul Formosa
      • Caitlin Roberts
    • Associates and Solicitors
      • Steven Hayles
      • Danielle Fitzgerald
      • Catherine Webster
      • Brigid Paterson
      • Rebecca Casanovas
      • Louise Stack
    • Notary Public
      • John Formosa
    • Migration Agent
      • Paul Formosa
  • Services
    • Legal Services (A-C)
      • Banking Law
      • Business Law
      • Civil Litigation
      • Conveyancing
      • Criminal Law
    • Legal Services (D-O)
      • Deceased Estates
      • Family Law
        • Getting Started
        • Start Now Online
        • Frequently asked questions
        • Domestic Violence
        • Local Services Guide
        • Meet our Family Lawyers
        • Family Law News Articles
      • Family Law Online
      • Immigration & Australian Visas
      • Notary Public
    • Legal Services (P-Z)
      • Personal Injuries
        • Compensation Claims
        • Motor Vehicle Accident
        • Workers Compensation
      • Planning Law
      • Powers of Attorney & Advance Health Directive
      • Property Law
      • Wills and Estates Planning
      • Workplace Law
  • Charitable Foundation
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Subscribe
  • Contact
    • Mackay
    • Proserpine
    • Whitsunday
  • Payments
    • Pay Now
    • Payment & Refunds

What recordings are admissible in Court?

September 10, 2019Samantha SticklanUncategorized

It is not unusual in parenting matters that involve conflict for either or both parents to record the other, particularly at changeovers.

The question often arises – can such recordings be used in court proceedings?

In a recent Federal Court case, Judge Heffernan heard a father’s application to exclude the mother’s video recordings of the father.

The recordings at the centre of the application, were made in secret by the mother.  Some were of changeover and the others were recordings of conversations between the father and the two children.

The Federal Circuit Court exercising in the Family Law jurisdiction has discretion under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) to exclude evidence if the value of what the evidence will show is outweighed by the risk of prejudice.  This means that improperly obtained evidence should be excluded unless the desirability of admitting it outweighs the undesirability of doing so.

Judge Heffernan found in this case that it was not improper for the mother to make video recordings of the changeovers, in circumstances where she had a legitimate concern for her personal safety, even having regard for the secrecy in which the recordings where made.  It was found that the recording of the changeovers was not contrary to any relevant Australian Law and should be admitted in evidence.

The recordings of the private conversations between the father and the children, however were considered inadmissible by the court.  In relation to those recordings, the mother was not able to convince the court of the importance of admitting the evidence, which was relevant to mothers’ case of parental alienation, outweighed the children’s right to have private conversations with their father.

The important message for clients to take home from this case is to remember that with technology at our finger tips, you are always at risk of being recorded and you should not do or say anything that you would not be happy for a judge to see.

Tags: Changeover, Custody, Family Law, Parent, Parenting Issues
Samantha Sticklan
http://www.macamiet.com.au/firm/samantha-sticklan
Samantha Sticklan is a Accredited Family Law Specialist and joined the Macrossan & Amiet in 2018 after 14 years at another Mackay law firm.
Previous post Heat of the moment resignations Next post Deceased Estates: What is Probate?

Related Articles

Child Support and Overseas Travel

June 18, 2018Samantha Sticklan

Beware of Delaying Commencing Family Law Property Settlement Proceedings After Separation!

December 3, 2015Darren Sekac

Child Support – Changing your Child Support Assessment

December 20, 2013Danielle Fitzgerald

News

  • Family Dispute Resolution Certificate
  • Welcome Greer
  • Double Demerit Points Queensland
  • Congratulations Louise
  • Family Law Act changes
  • The Queen’s Hat
  • What happens if you die without a Will?

Mackay | (07) 4944 2000

mac@macamiet.com.au
55 Gordon Street                                                    Mackay QLD 4740

Whitsunday | (07) 4948 4500

whitsundays@macamiet.com.au
Whitsunday Business Centre 230 Shute Harbour Road Cannonvale QLD 4802

Proserpine | (07) 4964 6900

proserpine@macamiet.com.au
15 Chapman Street                                         Proserpine QLD 4800
HomeAboutPeopleServicesCharitable FoundationNewsContactPayments
© 2016 Macrossan & Amiet. All rights reserved.
Designed and Hosted by Extend Digital