Subscribe
In the recent decision of Romero v Farstad Shipping (Indian Pacific) Pty Ltd the Full Federal Court of Australia decided that the terms of a company’s harassment and discrimination policy were contractually binding on the employer and that the employer’s failure to comply with the terms of the policy constituted a breach of contract.
This decision should serve as notice to employers to ensure that their own employment policies are properly drafted and fully complied with, as a breach of the policy could lead to an employee affected by the breach pursuing a claim for damages resulting from a breach of contract.
Facts of the Case
Lisa Romero was employed by Farstad Shipping as a sailor. During her employment, Ms Romero complained that a Captain of one of the vessels she sailed on bullied her because of her gender. Ms Romero lodged a claim in the Australian Human Rights Commission alleging that Farstad was responsible for the alleged discriminatory conduct of its employee. The complaint was not resolved before the Commission and Ms Romero subsequently lodged a claim in the Federal Court of Australia which included a further allegation that Farstad had breached its contract of employment with her during the course of the investigation of failing to adhere to its Workplace Harassment and Discrimination Policy (“the Policy”).
The Decision of the Federal Court at first instance
At first instance, a single Judge of the Federal Court concluded that: –
- There was no sex discrimination by the Captain or the company against Ms Romero.
- The Policy did not form part of Ms Romero’s contact of employment.
- Even if the Policy had constituted part of the contract of employment it was not so significantly departed from by Farstad as to constitute a breach of the Policy or contract of
employment.
The single Judge described the Policy as being ‘aspirational’ and, for that reason the terms of the Policy were not binding on the employer and did not form part of the contract of employment.
The Appeal
Ms Romero lodged an appeal against the Judge’s decision with the Full Federal Court. In her grounds of Appeal, Ms Romero did not appeal the Judge’s “factual” finding that there had been no sex discrimination. Instead Ms Romero appeal centred on a “legal” argument that the Policy did form part of her contact of employment and that Farstad had breached the policy causing her loss and damage.
The Decision of the Full Federal Court on appeal The Full Federal Court comprising three Judges allowed Ms Romero’s appeal and concluded that:
- The Policy did form part of the contract of employment;
- The Policy was not complied with; and
- The contract was breached;
Why the Full Federal Court concluded that the Policy formed part of the contract of employment.
In Romero, the Full Court held that the Policy formed part of the employment contract as:
The language used in this instance, taking the Policy as a whole, makes it clear that there is an expectation by the company that there will be mutual obligations. In return for the employee complying with the terms of the Policy, the employer gives a responsive assurance that complaints of non-compliance by other employees will be treated in a certain way.
Some of the circumstances which supported the Full Court’s findings were that:
- The Policy was the subject of an education program at the time of, or contemporaneous with, the offer of employment;
- Farstad provided the Policy to Romero;
- Romero was required to sign the Policy;
- The benefit in the Policy was a benefit ordinarily conferred in employment contracts; and
- There was regular reinforcement of this and other company policies on an ongoing basis.
The Full Court accepted that some aspects of the Policy were only aspirational but emphasised that:
… the specific obligations considered in this case were clearly ascertainable and quite capable of precise identification. There is thus no uncertainty or vagueness as to what the relevant terms of the Policy mean.
Many enforceable contracts contain provisions that can be described as aspirational Ramifications of the Decision for Employers It is important for employers to understand that their employment policies may form part of the terms of an employee’s contract of employment even though it is not referred to in a written contract of employment.
Whether an employment policy is incorporated into an employment contract will depend upon the language used in the policy and the context in which it is used.
If part of an employment policy uses language which is sufficiently certain to create mutual obligations on the employer and employee, an employer may be in breach of its contract of employment if it does not comply with those obligations under the policy.
This may be the case even if the remainder of the policy is “aspirational” in nature.
In response to this decision, Employers should ensure that they are fully aware of and are able to comply with the terms of their own employment policies as a contravention of the policy may give rise to a breach of contract.
If you would like further information about this decision, please contact Steven Hayles.

About the author
Steven Hayles
Director
LLB
Born and raised in Mackay, Steven completed his High School studies at Pioneer High School, before moving north to complete his law degree at Townsville’s James Cook University.
During his law degree, Steven was offered a position as a law clerk with Macrossan & Amiet during University vacation periods.
After spending several stints with Macrossan & Amiet during his degree, Steven elected to commence his solicitor’s traineeship with the firm in 2006. Steven was admitted as a solicitor of the Supreme Court of Queensland on 20 April 2007.
As a Mackay local, Steven is pleased to have secured a position with such a highly regarded local firm, that has a wealth of legal experience shared between its practitioners.
When Steven is not at work, he enjoys sporting pastimes including cricket, touch football and watching the National Rugby League.
About Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors
For over 100 years, Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors has been a leading local law firm in Mackay, with offices in Proserpine and Cannonvale servicing the Whitsundays region. Our experienced solicitors provide professional legal services to individuals, families and businesses across regional Queensland.
Whether you need representation in court, assistance buying or selling property, or advice on protecting your assets, our Mackay lawyers are committed to achieving the best possible outcome for you.
More Articles from Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors
News and Insights
Macrossan & Amiet congratulates Dyane Norton on promotion to Senior Associate
We are delighted to announce that Dyane Norton will be promoted to the position of Senior Associate at Macrossan & Amiet, effective 1 July 2026.

Quality Business Awards — Recognising Excellence and Trust
Our Criminal Law and Personal Injury teams receive Quality Business Awards recognition, celebrating exceptional service, professionalism, and commitment to client outcomes.

AML/CTF Reforms Are Coming: What Our Clients Need to Know
Australia’s AML/CTF reforms introduce new obligations for lawyers and other professionals from 1 July 2026, requiring client verification, due diligence and transaction scrutiny to prevent money laundering and terrorism financing risks.

Leaving Violence Program
The Leaving Violence Program provides financial assistance and support for eligible victim-survivors leaving intimate partner violence relationships, helping them rebuild safely.