Dismissal resulting from positive drug test

by Steven Hayles

May 5, 2015

Subscribe

drugtest1A worker who lodged an unsuccessful claim for Unfair Dismissal after he was dismissed for producing a positive drug test result at work in breach of the employer’s drug and alcohol management policy has been refused permission to appeal the decision by the Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission.

The decision emphasises the point that an employee may be dismissed simply because of the return of a single positive test result for an illicit substance taken outside of work hours. This may occur despite the fact that the test does not necessarily indicate that the worker is impaired or affected by the drug in carrying out their duties.

The employer in this case, BCS Infrastructure Support Pty Limited (“BCS”) held a contract with Qantas at Sydney Airport to maintain and service various types of equipment including baggage carousels and aerobridges. The work was classified as “Safety Sensitive Aviation Activities”. BCS employed Mr Sharp as a “Team Leader” in relation to this work.

On 10 February 2014, Mr Sharp was required to undertake a drug and alcohol test. Prior to undertaking the test, Mr Sharp admitted that he had smoked cannabis on the weekend. Interestingly, Mr Sharp was not stood down and he continued working until 12 February 2014.

On 12 February 2014, Mr Sharp was informed that his test had returned a “non-negative” result and he was stood down pending the provision of a report from a Medical Review Officer.

Confirmatory test results provided to the Medical Review Officer showed that Mr Sharp had tested positive for cannabinoids at a level more than 7 times threshold limit allowed for under BCS’s Drug and Alcohol Management Policy.

Mr Sharp was then required to participate in the formal disciplinary process outlined by the employer’s Drug and Alcohol Management Policy. This included a formal disciplinary meeting.

Following that meeting Mr Sharp provided a written response which stated that: –

  • He was not a regular user of cannabis;
  • He had smoked a single “joint” with friends on the Saturday prior to the test;
  • He did not feel impaired when he attended for work;
  • He acknowledged he had made a serious mistake;
  • He was prepared to submit to a program of ongoing or random testing if he were given a second chance; and
  • His length of service, his work record, his willingness to transfer to another worksite, his cooperation with the investigation process and his status as the primary breadwinner in his family should be taken into account.

 

At a further meeting on 21 February 2014, Mr Sharp was given notice that he was dismissed from his employment as a result of his test result effective immediately. Mr Sharp was paid his outstanding annual leave entitlements and paid 4 weeks’ pay in lieu of notice.

Mr Sharp subsequently lodged a claim for unfair dismissal with the Fair Work Commission.

The claim was heard before Vice President Catanzariti of the Fair Work Commission. Vice President Catanzariti determined that the return of a positive test was sufficiently serious to constitute serious misconduct and that there was a valid reason for Mr Sharp’s dismissal. Vice President Catanzariti also found that Mr Sharp was accorded procedural fairness and that his dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable. As a result of those finding, Mr Sharp’s claim for unfair dismissal was itself dismissed.

In his grounds of appeal to the Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission, Mr Sharp contended that the Vice President had erred: –

  • In concluding that Mr Sharp’s dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable and accordingly was not unfair.
  • In finding that the return of “a confirmed positive test result whilst at work” formed a valid reason for termination;
  • In finding, in his consideration that a non-negative urine test result constituted serious misconduct;
  • In finding that Mr Sharp’s conduct caused a serious and imminent risk to the reputation of BCS’s business;
  • In finding that the termination was not harsh;
  • In finding that Mr Sharp was accorded procedural fairness regarding the notification of the reasons for termination.

 

In reaching its decision to refuse Mr Sharp’s Appeal, the Full Bench concluded that an employer may be justified in dismissing an employee for any positive test result which breaches its drug and alcohol policy and, in particular, where any degree of impairment could constitute a threat to safety.

This was despite the Full Bench’s acknowledgement that there is no current scientific testing method available for accurately assessing impairment caused by the use of cannabis. The original decision of the Vice President was “not necessarily” the same decision that the members of the Full Bench would have reached if they had heard the Unfair Dismissal Claim at first instance and not on Appeal.

The Fair Work Commission’s reluctance to interfere with the employer’s decision to dismiss the employee in this case is typical of other recent decisions concerning employees who fail urine tests when they are employed in safety sensitive areas of work.1 This is despite the finding that the urine and saliva test results relied on by employers only indicate the presence of a drug in a person’s system and do not provide evidence of actual impairment while the employee was at work.

Whether the Fair Work Commission takes a similar approach to employees in non-safety sensitive areas of work remains to be seen. In any event the message to take home for employees is that the consumption of illicit substances such as cannabis over a weekend or whilst on leave may compromise their employment even if they are no longer demonstrating signs of impairment from their use of the drug.

Should you have a query regarding dismissals related to drug testing in the workplace, please contact Steven Hayles.

 

Notes
1Harbour City Ferries Pty Ltd v Toms [2014] FWCFB 6249, Collins v Lyndons Pty Ltd [2014] FWC 5903

 

 

 

share this article

About the author

Steven Hayles

Director

LLB

Born and raised in Mackay, Steven completed his High School studies at Pioneer High School, before moving north to complete his law degree at Townsville’s James Cook University.

During his law degree, Steven was offered a position as a law clerk with Macrossan & Amiet during University vacation periods.

After spending several stints with Macrossan & Amiet during his degree, Steven elected to commence his solicitor’s traineeship with the firm in 2006.  Steven was admitted as a solicitor of the Supreme Court of Queensland on 20 April 2007.

As a Mackay local, Steven is pleased to have secured a position with such a highly regarded local firm, that has a wealth of legal experience shared between its practitioners.

When Steven is not at work, he enjoys sporting pastimes including cricket, touch football and watching the National Rugby League.

About Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors

For over 100 years, Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors has been a leading local law firm in Mackay, with offices in Proserpine and Cannonvale servicing the Whitsundays region. Our experienced solicitors provide professional legal services to individuals, families and businesses across regional Queensland.

Whether you need representation in court, assistance buying or selling property, or advice on protecting your assets, our Mackay lawyers are committed to achieving the best possible outcome for you.

More Articles from Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors

News and Insights
July 1, 2026

Macrossan & Amiet congratulates Dyane Norton on promotion to Senior Associate

We are delighted to announce that Dyane Norton will be promoted to the position of Senior Associate at Macrossan & Amiet, effective 1 July 2026.

Read Article
June 16, 2026

Quality Business Awards — Recognising Excellence and Trust

Our Criminal Law and Personal Injury teams receive Quality Business Awards recognition, celebrating exceptional service, professionalism, and commitment to client outcomes.

Read Article
June 16, 2026

AML/CTF Reforms Are Coming: What Our Clients Need to Know

Australia’s AML/CTF reforms introduce new obligations for lawyers and other professionals from 1 July 2026, requiring client verification, due diligence and transaction scrutiny to prevent money laundering and terrorism financing risks.

Read Article
June 15, 2026

Leaving Violence Program

The Leaving Violence Program provides financial assistance and support for eligible victim-survivors leaving intimate partner violence relationships, helping them rebuild safely.

Read Article

Select a location to see it's reviews