The Racial Discrimination Act and “the Right to be Bigots”

by Macrossan & Amiet

May 26, 2014

Subscribe

Over the past month there has been some fiery political rhetoric on “free speech” and the proposed amendments to the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 ‘the Act’).

The concern by the legislature to balance the prevention of racial vilification and the need to not unduly restrict freedom of speech is not novel. While Australia does not have legislation to protect the personal right to free speech (per se), it is considered a universal human right inalienable to all people. That said the right to free speech is not absolute. It must be balanced against other relevant values and interests such as dignity and equality.

Some restrictions to the right to free speech are reasonably necessary to allow every person in Australia to live peacefully and with dignity. The harms caused by racist words and conduct have been well documented. The purpose of the Act is to ensure that no person in Australia need live in fear because
of his or her race or ethnicity. The issue at hand is whether the restrictions on free speech in the Act are proportionate to serve the Act’s purpose.

The Act in its current form prohibits public acts which are reasonably likely to “offend, insult, humiliate or intimidate” other people and which are done because of their race, colour or national or ethnic origin.

To mitigate the scope of the prohibition there is a very wide exception for acts done reasonably and in good faith for purposes including fair comment on matters of public interest. This means that it is illegal to offend another person on the grounds of race unless the offence was by way of a genuine and reasonable comment on a matter of relevance to the general populace. The Abbot government is now suggesting that the bar is set too low. In Senator Brandis’ own words “people do have a right to be bigots.”

The Government wants to limit the scope of the offence to acts that are reasonably likely to “vilify” or “intimidate” on similar grounds, with vilify meaning “inciting hatred” and “intimidate” meaning “causing fear of physical harm”. Both words have been narrowly defined in the draft bill. The Human Rights Commission points out that the proposed definition of vilification “excludes conduct that is degrading”, adding that the definition of intimidation excludes “conduct causing emotional or psychological harm”.

Another proposal put forward by the Government is the introduction of an exemption for anything “spoken, broadcast, published or communicated in the course of participating in the public discussion of any political, social, cultural, religious, artistic, academic or scientific matter”. The proposed exemption is not qualified by reasonableness or good faith. The Human Rights Commission notes that it allows for “racist abuse [to be] offered up in the course of public discussion”.

Under the proposed exemption, holocaust denial would be legal, as would a statement that some races are genetically superior to others. How far should freedom of speech protect offensive or hurtful language? The Government is faced with the complex task of balancing the right to free speech with other freedoms. A balance needs to be found between the right to say whatever you please, and the right not to be vilified in a public place on the grounds of your skin color.

share this article

About the author

Macrossan & Amiet

Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors is one of Queensland’s oldest law firms. It has been serving the people of Mackay and the surrounding districts since the late 19th Century, providing quality legal services to all of its clients.

About Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors

For over 100 years, Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors has been a leading local law firm in Mackay, with offices in Proserpine and Cannonvale servicing the Whitsundays region. Our experienced solicitors provide professional legal services to individuals, families and businesses across regional Queensland.

Whether you need representation in court, assistance buying or selling property, or advice on protecting your assets, our Mackay lawyers are committed to achieving the best possible outcome for you.

More Articles from Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors

News and Insights
July 1, 2026

Macrossan & Amiet congratulates Dyane Norton on promotion to Senior Associate

We are delighted to announce that Dyane Norton will be promoted to the position of Senior Associate at Macrossan & Amiet, effective 1 July 2026.

Read Article
June 16, 2026

Quality Business Awards — Recognising Excellence and Trust

Our Criminal Law and Personal Injury teams receive Quality Business Awards recognition, celebrating exceptional service, professionalism, and commitment to client outcomes.

Read Article
June 16, 2026

AML/CTF Reforms Are Coming: What Our Clients Need to Know

Australia’s AML/CTF reforms introduce new obligations for lawyers and other professionals from 1 July 2026, requiring client verification, due diligence and transaction scrutiny to prevent money laundering and terrorism financing risks.

Read Article
June 15, 2026

Leaving Violence Program

The Leaving Violence Program provides financial assistance and support for eligible victim-survivors leaving intimate partner violence relationships, helping them rebuild safely.

Read Article

Select a location to see it's reviews