“Dennis Denuto” Defamation Claim Dismissed

by Steven Hayles

December 3, 2015

Subscribe

An Ipswich lawyer who sued a man for $250,000.00 after he called him “Dennis Denuto” has had his Claim dismissed by the District Court.

Brett Smith commenced defamation proceedings against Kenneth Lucht after he took issue with Mr Lucht referring to him on multiple occasions as “Dennis Denuto” the lawyer character from the classic Australian film “The Castle”.

For those not familiar with the film, Dennis Denuto is the solicitor who represents the film’s protagonist, Dale Kerrigan in a legal fight against the compulsory acquisition of the Kerrigan’s family home. Dennis Denuto is portrayed as likeable and well-intentioned but inexperienced in matters of constitutional law and not qualified to appear in person in litigation of that nature. During the film, Mr Denuto’s main submission to the Court in support of his client’s case concerned “the vibe”.

The statements which Mr Lucht made regarding Brett Smith occurred after Brett Smith agreed to act for his daughter-in-law in family law proceedings against her former husband, Mr Lucht.

The first statement which referred to Brett Smith as “Dennis Denuto” was made by Mr Lucht via email to his former wife (Mr Smith’s daughter-in-law). Subsequent statements which referred to Brett Smith as “Dennis Denuto” were made orally by Mr Lucht to his former wife and her husband (Mr Smith’s son) during a child handover outside a restaurant.

Mr Lucht defended the defamation proceedings brought by Mr Smith on a number of grounds including section 33 of the Defamation Act (Qld) 2005 (“the Act”). That section provides a defence to the publication of defamatory matter if the defendant proves that the circumstances of publication were such that the plaintiff was unlikely to sustain any harm.

In dismissing the Mr Smith’s claim, in his judgment delivered on 20 November 2015, Judge Moynihan found that:-

“at the time the statements were made, Mr Smith was unlikely to sustain any harm to his reputation as the statements were confined to two members of his family with whom the defendant was in dispute, and they were able to make their own assessment of the imputation.”

Had the statements been made to persons who were not members of Mr Smith’s family and not involved in the family law dispute then Mr Lucht would likely not have succeeded with his defence under section 33 of the Act.

Had Mr Lucht not succeeded with his defence under section 33 of the Act, Judge Moynihan assessed that an appropriate award of damages for Mr Smith’s claim would have been an amount of $10,000.00 including interest.

A full copy of the Judge’s decision can be accessed at  http://archive.sclqld.org.au/qjudgment/2015/QDC15-289.pdf

It remains to be seen whether Mr Smith decides to take his case further on appeal as was the case in “The Castle”.

Our firm has experience in handling defamation claims on behalf of Plaintiffs and Defendants.

If you would like further advice with respect to your rights regarding the law of defamation including as to whether any defences are applicable under the Defamation Act (Qld) 2005 please contact our office to make an appointment.

 

 

 

share this article

About the author

Steven Hayles

Director

LLB

Born and raised in Mackay, Steven completed his High School studies at Pioneer High School, before moving north to complete his law degree at Townsville’s James Cook University.

During his law degree, Steven was offered a position as a law clerk with Macrossan & Amiet during University vacation periods.

After spending several stints with Macrossan & Amiet during his degree, Steven elected to commence his solicitor’s traineeship with the firm in 2006.  Steven was admitted as a solicitor of the Supreme Court of Queensland on 20 April 2007.

As a Mackay local, Steven is pleased to have secured a position with such a highly regarded local firm, that has a wealth of legal experience shared between its practitioners.

When Steven is not at work, he enjoys sporting pastimes including cricket, touch football and watching the National Rugby League.

About Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors

For over 100 years, Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors has been a leading local law firm in Mackay, with offices in Proserpine and Cannonvale servicing the Whitsundays region. Our experienced solicitors provide professional legal services to individuals, families and businesses across regional Queensland.

Whether you need representation in court, assistance buying or selling property, or advice on protecting your assets, our Mackay lawyers are committed to achieving the best possible outcome for you.

More Articles from Macrossan & Amiet Solicitors

News and Insights
July 1, 2026

Macrossan & Amiet congratulates Dyane Norton on promotion to Senior Associate

We are delighted to announce that Dyane Norton will be promoted to the position of Senior Associate at Macrossan & Amiet, effective 1 July 2026.

Read Article
June 16, 2026

Quality Business Awards — Recognising Excellence and Trust

Our Criminal Law and Personal Injury teams receive Quality Business Awards recognition, celebrating exceptional service, professionalism, and commitment to client outcomes.

Read Article
June 16, 2026

AML/CTF Reforms Are Coming: What Our Clients Need to Know

Australia’s AML/CTF reforms introduce new obligations for lawyers and other professionals from 1 July 2026, requiring client verification, due diligence and transaction scrutiny to prevent money laundering and terrorism financing risks.

Read Article
June 15, 2026

Leaving Violence Program

The Leaving Violence Program provides financial assistance and support for eligible victim-survivors leaving intimate partner violence relationships, helping them rebuild safely.

Read Article

Select a location to see it's reviews