Local people. Local expertise. Industry leaders.
07) 4944 2000
Facebook
LinkedIn
MacAmiet Logo White
  • Home
  • About
    • Profile
    • Privacy and Credit Reporting Policy
    • History
    • Career Opportunities
  • People
    • Directors
      • Gene Paterson
      • Pat Carroll
      • John Formosa
      • Darren Sekac
      • Stuart Naylor
      • Andrew Telford
      • Samantha Sticklan
      • Paul Formosa
      • Caitlin Roberts
    • Associates and Solicitors
      • Steven Hayles
      • Danielle Fitzgerald
      • Brigid Paterson
      • Rebecca Casanovas
      • Dyane Norton
      • Jessica Kay
      • Nelson Turner
    • Notary Public
      • John Formosa
    • Migration Agent
      • Paul Formosa
  • Services
    • Legal Services (A-C)
      • Banking Law
      • Business Law
      • Civil Litigation
      • Conveyancing
      • Criminal Law
    • Legal Services (D-O)
      • Deceased Estates
      • Family Law
        • Getting Started
        • Start Now Online
        • Frequently asked questions
        • Domestic Violence
        • Local Services Guide
        • Meet our Family Lawyers
        • Family Law News Articles
      • Family Law Online
      • Immigration & Australian Visas
      • Notary Public
    • Legal Services (P-Z)
      • Personal Injuries
        • Compensation Claims
        • Motor Vehicle Accident
        • Workers Compensation
      • Planning Law
      • Powers of Attorney & Advance Health Directive
      • Property Law
      • Wills and Estates Planning
      • Workplace Law
  • Charitable Foundation
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Subscribe
  • Contact
    • Mackay
    • Proserpine
    • Whitsunday
    • Solicitor Gold Coast
  • Payments
    • Pay Now
    • Payment & Refunds

SMSF – do you have a Binding Death Nomination

March 25, 2019Stuart NaylorStuart Naylor

The importance of a Binding Death Nomination for members of Self-Managed Superannuation Funds (SMSF) is often underestimated.  A member of a SMSF has one method available to him or her to ensure the benefits are paid in a particular way or to a particular person on death; the making of a Binding Death Nomination.  This will only be available if the terms of the Trustee establishing the fund permit the making of a Binding Death Nomination.  Most SMSF Trust Deeds will permit this.

The importance of a Binding Nomination is sometimes underestimated even by advisers.  It can sometimes be assumed that because the Trust Deed confers the Trustee a discretion to decide how the benefit is paid that a Binding Death Nomination is less important.  This is not accurate.  Whilst most Trust Deeds will give a certain amount of discretion to the Trustee a member’s superannuation benefit on death can only be paid to someone who falls within the definition of dependent under the governing legislation or otherwise to the member’s estate (which would then be distributed in accordance with the member’s Will).

Not only is the Trustee’s discretion limited by the legislation but increasingly the exercise of the discretion is being challenged in the Courts and on occasions successfully challenged.  Most challenges arise where an individual Trustee decides to distribute the entire benefit to themselves.

Many Trust Deeds confer what purports to be an absolute discretion on the Trustee and expressly authorise conflict transactions.  Whilst those provisions are helpful a Trustee must exercise its discretion regarding payment of any death benefit; 1 in good faith; 2 upon real and genuine consideration; 3 in accordance with the purposes for which the discretion was conferred.

The Trustee is not under any obligation to state its reasons for the exercise of the discretion.

A Trustee’s exercise of discretion can be challenged if it was exercised in bad faith, arbitrarily, irresponsibly or irrelevantly.  Bad faith can be shown if the Trustee does not consider all relevant factors.  Relevant factors have been found by Courts to include:-

  • The intention of the deceased;
  • The relationship between the deceased and any eligible dependent;
  • The financial circumstances and needs of each eligible dependent.

If competing eligible dependents are in similar financial circumstances with similar needs then it may be easier to show that the exercise of discretion was in bad faith if it involves a decision to make payment to only one of the eligible dependents to the exclusion of all others.

It may reasonably be expected that there will be an increase in the number of challenges to the exercise of discretion.  There is also now a substantial body of case law establishing that where the Trustee of the superannuation fund is also the Executor then it will be breach of the Trustee’s duty as Executor to seek to have the superannuation benefit paid to themselves rather than the estate.

A Binding Death Benefit Nomination is a simple and cost-effective way to avoid uncertainty and risk.  It is wise to take professional advice in relation to the preparation of the Binding Death Benefit Nomination as it is vital that the requirements of the Trust Deed be met strictly.  If those requirements are not met, then there is a substantial risk that the Binding Death Benefit Nomination would be found to be ineffective.

Anyone who has a SMSF and does not have a Binding Death Benefit Nomination in place would be well advised to seek advice and put in place a Binding Death Benefit Nomination.

 

Tags: Estate Planning, Self Managed Super Funds, Succession Planning, Superannuation, Wills
Stuart Naylor
https://www.macamiet.com.au/firm/stuart-naylor/
Stuart Naylor commenced working at Macrossan & Amiet in 1996 after having completed Bachelor of Commerce and Bachelor of Laws Degrees. Stuart became a partner in the firm on 1 August 2004 and was appointed the firms Managing Director in June 2015.
Previous post Personal Injury Claims Against the Nominal Defendant Next post An End of an Era

Related Articles

Superannuation: Who Gets It When You Die

September 26, 2013Stuart Naylor

Reclaim your Super

January 30, 2017Danielle Fitzgerald

What is Estate Planning?

October 9, 2020Stuart Naylor

News

  • Applicant Receives Deceased’s Property on Basis of a Verbal Promise Fulfilled
  • Medical Negligence Claims
  • Social Media Defamation
  • Driving with an Interstate Driver Licence or Motor Vehicle
  • New Enduring Power of Attorney and Advance Health Directive Forms
  • Insurers Liable for Business Interruption Caused by COVID-19
  • Child Support: Applying for a Change of Assessment

Mackay | (07) 4944 2000

mac@macamiet.com.au
55 Gordon Street                                 Mackay QLD 4740

Whitsunday | (07) 4948 4500

whitsundays@macamiet.com.au
Whitsunday Business Centre 230 Shute Harbour Road Cannonvale QLD 4802

Proserpine | (07) 4964 6900

proserpine@macamiet.com.au
15 Chapman Street                         Proserpine QLD 4800

Gold Coast | 0419 714 015

dsekac@macamiet.com.au

 

Available by appointment & home visits available

HomeAboutPeopleServicesCharitable FoundationNewsContactPayments
© 2020 Macrossan & Amiet. All rights reserved.
Designed and Hosted by Extend Digital